Former Vice President Joe Biden, the current frontrunner, was the target of many of the candidates’ attacks. But Biden struck a shaper and more aggressive tone than in the first debate when he came off as shaky and flustered.
The former vice president was repeatedly forced to defend his decades-old political record against pointed attacks from his younger, diverse rivals, who charged that Biden’s eight-year relationship with former President Barack Obama was not reason enough to earn the Democratic nomination.
Joining Biden on stage were Senators Michael Bennet, Cory Booker, Kristen Gillibrand and Kamala Harris, Representative Tulsi Gabbard, New York Mayor Bill de Blasio, Washington Governor Jay Inslee, former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Julian Castro and entrepreneur Andrew Yang
On Tuesday, a different 10 candidates took the stage, with moderates and progressive clashing over healthcare and socialism.
Although the first primary votes won’t come for six more months, there is a sense of urgency for the lower-tier candidates to break out. More than half the field could be blocked from the next round of debates altogether – and possibly pushed out of the race – if they fail to reach new polling and fundraising thresholds implemented by the Democratic National Committee.
Here’s where Wednesday’s group of 10 stood on some of the major issues.
Biden and Harris clashed over their dueling healthcare plans
The pair had a tense exchange during the opening debates last month in Miami – and wasted little time before going at it again Wednesday.
Harris said her proposal would extend health insurance to all Americans, while Biden’s would “leave out” almost 10 million.
Biden said her plan is too expensive and would cause many people to lose their current, employer-based health insurance. He said Harris isn’t being straight about that, adding, “You can’t beat President Trump with double-talk.”
Harris said Biden is “simply inaccurate.”
Bennet also weighed in, suggesting Harris hasn’t been up-front about planks of her “Medicare for all” plan.
Bennet charged that the plan would mean a tax increase for the middle class and outlaw private insurance
Harris released details of her healthcare plan earlier this week. It would allow private Medicare plans that follow certain federal guidelines, and it would include a tax on household income over $100,000.
Harris accused Bennet of using “Republican talking points”, defending her plan by insisting it doesn’t make anything illegal, but rather “separates the employer from healthcare”.
Biden and Castro clashed over immigration.
Castro has promised to make crossing the US-Mexico border irregularly punishable by a civil penalty and is repeated that call Wednesday.
He said that doesn’t mean endorsing “open borders”, but said some in his party, including some on the debate stage, have “taken the bait” and fallen for a Republican talking point.
Biden said he doesn’t support decriminalising such border crossing. He also said he never heard Castro “talk about any of this while he was secretary”.
Castro responded, “It looks like one of us has learned the lessons of the past and one of us hasn’t.”
Booker then took his turn to go after Biden over the flaws he saw in former President Barack Obama’s immigration policies.
Booker likened Biden’s stance on immigration to that of Trump.
Booker said Biden’s proposal to allow immigrants who attend American universities and earn doctorate degrees to remain in the country for seven years plays into the hands of Republicans.
He compared it to Trump’s preference for immigrants from countries like Sweden and Norway over immigrants from African and Caribbean nations – which the president referred to as “s***hole countries”.
Booker said Biden “can’t have it both ways”.
“You invoke President Obama more than anybody in this campaign. You can’t do it when it’s convenient and then dodge it when it’s not,” Booker said.
As expected, Trump was a major target in Wednesday night’s debate. The event comes after weeks of racist and racially-charged comments from the president, including telling four congresswomen of colour to “go back” to where they came from and calling the black-majority city of Baltimore “rat-infested”.
Some of Wednesday night’s candidates took the opportunity to call Trump a “racist”.
“We can no longer allow a white nationalist to be in the White House,” Inslee said as candidates debated immigration policy.
Castro followed up later by coming Trump a “racist”.
Gillibrand said she feels responsibility as “a white woman” to challenge institutional racism and explain what white privilege is and means. She said it’s not just up to the two leading black candidates, Harris and Booker, to talk about race.
Discussing race, Harris charged that Biden’s past work with segregationists in the US Senate could have prevented Obama from becoming the nation’s first black president.
“Had those segregationists had their way, I would not be a member of the United States Senate, Cory Booker would not be a member of the United States Senate, and Barack Obama would not have been in a position to nominate” Biden to become vice president.
When pressed, Biden repeatedly leaned on his relationship with Obama.
“We’re talking about things that occurred a long, long time ago,” Biden said. He added: “Everybody’s talking about how terrible I am on these issues. Barack Obama knew who I was.”
Biden was flanked by Harris on one side and Booker on the other. As Biden greeted Harris onstage moments before the opening statements, he quipped, “Go easy on me, kid.”
During his opening remarks, Biden said Trump was tearing at the “fabric of America” and highlighted the value of diversity in his opening statement.
“Mr President, this is America,” Biden said of the diverse slate of candidates on stage.
Harris also referenced Trump’s divisive presidency.
“This becomes a moment we must fight for the best of who we are,” Harris said. “We are better than this.”
Gillibrand said engaging with climate change will be her top priority if elected president – but the first thing she’ll do if elected is “Clorox the Oval office”.
Democratic presidential candidates largely agreed on the overall goal of addressing climate change but differing in degrees of urgency.
Inslee said Biden’s climate plan doesn’t move the nation fast enough off of fossil fuels.
Inslee said “middle-ground solutions like the vice president has proposed … are not going to save us. Too little, too late is too dangerous”.
Biden said he is committed to re-engaging the international community on combating climate change and re-joining the Paris Climate Accord.